A Second X-Ray, a Second Look: What Repeat Films Add in Diabetic Foot Osteomyelitis #ActAgainstAmputation

A foot X-ray can look reassuring while the foot in front of us tells a different story. When we’re worried about bone infection, what does a second film add? And do we learn more from comparing the two films than from looking at the later one alone? Those are two different questions.

In Wound Repair and Regeneration, Henry Harrison, Kerensa Beekman, Rimke Lagrand, Larry Lavery, Mario Maas, and Edgar Peters put both questions to the test.

Illustrated foot X-rays and diagnostic AUCs in 34 cases: baseline 0.52, roughly six-week follow-up 0.64, both together 0.65. Follow-up alone and both together did not differ significantly.
Original AI-assisted infographic based on Harrison and colleagues. The X-rays are illustrations, not patient images. Six weeks was the study interval, not a recommended wait.

What changed on the second look?

The team went back to 34 cases of suspected diabetic foot osteomyelitis in the BeBoP cohort. All had an initial film, another at about six weeks, and a percutaneous bone biopsy. In 27 cases, histopathology, bone culture, or both met the study definition of osteomyelitis. Two radiologists and two non-radiologists rated the likelihood of infection on the baseline films, the follow-up films, and both together.

The pooled AUC was 0.52 at baseline, 0.64 at follow-up, and 0.65 with both films. AUC describes how well a test separates cases with and without the condition; 0.50 is chance-level discrimination. These numbers aren’t percent accuracy.

In a separate analysis, readers were more likely to classify cases correctly when they had both films than when they had only the first. But the study found no statistically significant improvement in AUC when the first film was added to the later one. The later film carried more of the diagnostic signal in this sample. With only seven biopsy-negative cases, the study can’t rule out an incremental benefit from comparison.

Radiologists did better on the baseline classification comparison, but the study didn’t show a reader-experience advantage in AUC. Agreement was moderate (κ = 0.44). With four readers, I wouldn’t take that as a reason to discount expert interpretation.

Get the baseline. Don’t wait on the X-ray.

Plain films remain a useful first step. They give us a baseline and can reveal findings beyond bone changes, such as gas or a foreign body. The IWGDF/IDSA guideline recommends using them alongside probe-to-bone testing and inflammatory markers in the initial workup. When suspicion remains high after a normal film, a repeat in two to three weeks can help; MRI is recommended when the diagnosis remains in doubt after the initial assessment. A severe or complicated infection calls for urgent assessment, not another scheduled film.

That distinction fits the approach in our Nature Primer on diabetic foot disease: put imaging in the context of the wound, perfusion and the rest of the clinical assessment. A repeat film can add useful evidence. A normal first film shouldn’t overrule a concerning foot.

Read the study

Harrison HSG, Beekman KM, Lagrand RS, Lavery LA, Maas M, Peters EJG. Diagnostic utility of serial radiography in foot osteomyelitis in people with diabetes: influence of operator experience on test performance. Wound Repair Regen. 2026;34(6):e70240. doi:10.1111/wrr.70240.

Evidence note: Study details are based on the published abstract and figure legends.

#ActAgainstAmputation #DiabeticFoot #Osteomyelitis #LimbPreservation

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Up ↑

Verified by MonsterInsights